It Wasn't The Government Saying Goodbye Too Soon

I recall one of our Thursday lunches, to which the physician organizer invited representatives of a local hospice to talk about hospices and specifically about their hospice's services to patients and their families. It was an informative interesting talk, enlivened by a lot of questions from doctors. But the really interesting conversation came after the hospice people left.

Several cancer specialists angrily complained about a local hospital. These physicians found that immediately upon a patient's diagnosis of cancer, someone in the hospital (perhaps social services?) arranged for a prompt hospice consult before a cancer specialist could review the case with the patient, his or her family, the patient's primary physician, pathologists, radiologists, and other experts. Patients and their families were having "the crepe" hung for them, with the gloomiest possible prognosis. The cancer specialists said that patients were being whisked out of the hospital, consigned to hospice care, when they could have been treated palliatively (even during hospice care), to relieve pain and suffering and perhaps to prolong life, or could have explored the possibility of an effort at curative treatment.

Now, this wasn't the government convening a "let's shorten your life" committee. The physicians felt this was an apparent hospital policy.

Before we again shake our fingers at Senators and Representatives, and accuse our government of rushing people off to die to save money, let's think about other actors: insurers, hospitals and institutions which - if there are no ethical safeguards - could be advantaged by hastening the process of dying.